Skip to main content

Career Planning: Is there hope for struggling teens?

Guest Blogger
Jared C. Schultz, Ph.D., CRC, LVRC, HS-BCP

I have witnessed both the unproductive and productive side of vocational assessment. I remember taking the Strong Interest Inventory in high school. My guidance counselor called me into his office and shared with me that I should be a “Mortician and Embalmer”. This is a great profession to be sure; but not a future that will attract the girls. I had a choice; I could either disregard the results of the test, or face a life of… well… you get the picture.


Unfortunately, I think that many people have similar experiences. When vocational and career assessments are done in a fragmented manner or in isolation of the comprehensive process, it leads people to believe that these processes are generally useless. The process of providing a career evaluation is grounded in the task of matching a person to a vocation or career goal. We comprehensively assess aspects of the person and the work environment to determine the level of “fit”.





The following are assessment tools that are utilized to do this. It is critical to remember that focusing on one tool will give incomplete results that are difficult to implement into an Individual Education Plan or Therapeutic Treatment Plan.

1.      Interest Inventories – These instruments measure and report on types of jobs that may be of interest to the student. They are limited to interest only, and do not address the other factors that are required for success in the workplace.

2.      Aptitude Testing – These assessments address an individual’s capacity to learn skills and knowledge in specific areas. Examples of areas evaluated are spatial aptitude, numerical aptitude, motor coordination, verbal aptitude, math aptitude, etc. The focus is on future development and capacity.

3.      Ability / Achievement Assessment – These assessments measure current abilities, and answer the question, “What can this person do now?” The focus is on meeting a minimum criterion for entering a profession. This type of information may include specific ability or achievement tests, and may include academic testing and academic information.

4.      Value Assessment – Examines the value preferences of the individual relevant to the workplace. Again, the focus is on finding an employment setting and job type that is congruent with the value set of the individual.

5.      Personality Testing – Assesses the basic constructs of the individual’s personality. Personality testing is helpful for assessing the match with a particular vocational goal, but in isolation does not provide an adequate picture of potential success.


These assessment areas provide information related to the “person” part of the equation. A useful career evaluation will also provide information regarding the “environment”. This is referred to as occupational information, and entails information on the work environment of specific jobs, as well as labor market surveys. Best practice in vocational and career evaluation will also include observing the interaction of the person in specific work situations through work trials, work samples, and situation assessments.


Finally, a strong career evaluation process will recognize the dynamic nature of career exploration, particularly given the developmental stage of the student. It should provide direction to the student, family, and allied professionals on how to facilitate the continued growth and development of the student.


Simply put, the vocational and career evaluation process for adolescents and young adults who struggle with ASD, NLD, RAD, substance abuse, depression or anxiety disorders is much more complex than completing a few interest inventories.

If you found this post helpful, you may want to read this other post entitled;

The Value of Work in Recovery








Labels:

Comments

Leslie Scarpa said…
So this leaves me wondering, how do these kids, particularly kids who have successfully completed therapeutic programs and are ready to move forward with their lives, get a chance at college or other opportunities. Often times their grade points are below their ability due to their bumps in the road along the way. How frustrating to have straightened their life out only to be turned down by a college because of a hardship. This is a problem facing one of my clients.
November 16, 2011 at 6:19 PM
Post a Comment

Popular posts from this blog

The Young Boy and the Rattlesnake

By Stephen C. Schultz (Editors note: This is a story used in a Wilderness Treatment Program. Many come to this program having struggled with depression, anxiety and substance use.)   Many years ago there was a young Native American who lived in the very land you are residing in. He decided to seek wisdom by journeying to the top of Indian Peak. As he approached the base of the mountain he came across a rattlesnake that slithered beside him. The snake coiled as if to strike and the young boy moved back quickly in fear of being struck by the snake’s deadly venom. At that instant the snake spoke to the boy saying, “Don’t be afraid of me, I mean you no harm. I come to you to ask a favor. I see that you are about to traverse to the top of Indian Peak and was hoping that you may be willing to place me in your satchel so that I don’t have to make the long journey alone.” The young boy surprised by the snake’s request quickly responded by turning down the offer, stating, ...
4 comments
Read more

Measuring What Matters: Oxbow’s Edge in Predicting Progress

By Stephen C. Schultz Therapists are highly trained to guide, support, and assess progress. Yet, research continues to show that even experienced clinicians have mixed results at predicting which clients will improve, drop out, or struggle in therapy. This isn’t a critique of therapists—it’s a reality supported by data. And for those who place trust in residential treatment programs—families, school districts, educational consultants, and Managed Care Organizations (MCOs)—this insight is critical. At Oxbow Academy , we take this seriously. That’s why we use validated, research-backed tools to supplement clinical intuition and track meaningful progress in real time. Research Shows: Intuition Isn’t Enough In a foundational study by Hannan et al. (2005), therapists failed to recognize which of their clients were likely to experience treatment failure—even when objective outcome data pointed to risks. Similarly, Hatfield et al. (2010) demonstrated that therapists tend to overestima...
1 comment
Read more

When Emotional Pain Looks Like Manipulation: Oxbow Academy

By Stephen C. Schultz The teenage years are often full of complexity—especially for young people who struggle with impulse control, social understanding, or emotional regulation in relation to Problematic Sexual Behavior (PSB). For some, this difficulty is compounded by co-occurring conditions like Autism Spectrum Disorder (ASD), ADHD, or Nonverbal Learning Disorder (NLD) . These teens may unintentionally find themselves caught in compulsive, confusing, or embarrassing situations—sometimes involving inappropriate behavior with siblings, neighbors and friends or accessing dark corners of the internet. As these patterns continue, parents are often left feeling overwhelmed, frightened, and unsure of what to do next. Some worry that law enforcement or government agencies might get involved. Others have already experienced the fear of having electronics confiscated or home environments scrutinized. In the midst of this chaos, many parents recognize that their child’s behavior isn’t just a...
Post a Comment
Read more